Who Are the Green Berets Supposed to Be? Revisiting the Special Forces Identity Crisis

Authored by:
Greg E. Metzgar
Published on 8/5/2025
Digital Only

The U.S. Army Special Forces (SF)—better known as the Green Berets—stand at a crossroads. After more than two decades of continuous conflict and evolving mission sets, Special Forces Branch faces a profound question: Who are the Green Berets supposed to be?


Colonel Edward C. Croot's "identity crisis" and the rebuttal by Sergeant Major (Retired) David Shell are not a superficial branding issue. It should be encouraging to Special Forces Branch to see two of its members debating a timely topic rather than allowing outside pundits to examine and attempt to hypothesize critically about the SF Branch.


See also: Mission or Meaning? Rethinking the Identity Crisis in U.S. Army Special Forces by Siamak T. Naficy, PhD, and W5 Maurice "Duc" DuClos.


Access as a web page by clicking here or on the image below.

   READ NOW   
Topics